INDEPENDENT EVALUATION FRAMEWORK

Verification Tiers & Scoring Methodology

Our objective, four-pillar evaluation framework assesses how verified enterprises structurally protect their 100% profit lock, enforce fair executive compensation, and ensure full public transparency.

Why We Evaluate and Tier Verified Businesses

Every business featured in the Profit 4 Good directory has satisfied our strict core entry standard: 100% of net profits are dedicated to charitable or public-benefit purposes, with zero private shareholder dividend extraction.

However, the legal mechanisms and governance models used to enforce that lock differ across international legal systems. To provide complete clarity to consumers, corporate procurement officers, and institutional partners, we score and categorize each business into transparent Verification Tiers based on their corporate structure, executive pay governance, and audit transparency.

The Four Evaluative Pillars

Each enterprise is rigorously scored out of 100% across four independent dimensions:

Pillar 120% Weight

Distinct Commercial Entity & Marketplace Trading

The business must operate as a standalone, registered commercial company or distinct trading enterprise selling goods or services in the open market on standard commercial terms, competing directly on quality and price rather than operating purely as a fundraising entity.

Pillar 230% Weight

100% Net Profit & Structural Non-Distribution Lock

Assesses the legal permanence of the 100% profit lock. Highest scores are awarded to businesses with structural irrevocability (100% equity owned by a registered charity, public foundation, or perpetual purpose trust), followed by statutory government-regulated asset locks (such as UK CICs and Canadian C3s) and binding corporate donation covenants.

Pillar 325% Weight

Executive Compensation & Non-Distribution Integrity

Scrutinizes executive remuneration to ensure profit is not privately extracted through inflated salaries or consulting fees. Evaluates fair market rates, formal salary caps (such as 5:1 ratios), accredited living wages, and oversight by independent non-executive boards.

Pillar 425% Weight

Public Transparency & Verifiable Evidence

Measures the depth of publicly accessible verification. Highest scores reflect public annual statutory disclosures (IRS Form 990, CRA T3010, UK Charity Commission filings, ACNC registers), independent annual financial audits, and open line-item reporting of charitable distributions.

The Three Verification Tiers

How total evaluation scores correlate with structural safeguards and governance models:

TIER 1

EXCELLENT

95% – 100% Score

The Institutional Gold Standard. The highest level of structural protection against private wealth extraction. The operating business is either 100% wholly owned by a registered charity, public foundation, or perpetual purpose trust, or is structured as a non-profit company limited by guarantee without share capital.

Ownership Archetype

Charity-Owned Company / Foundation-Owned / CLG

Executive Pay Oversight

Governed by Independent Charity Trustees

Public Disclosures

Annual Form 990 / T3010 / Charity Commission Audits

Capital Leakage Risk

Near-Zero (Structural Legal Impossibility)

TIER 2

HIGH INTEGRITY

90% – 94% Score

Statutory Asset Locks & Certified Enterprise Models. Businesses operating under government-enforced statutory asset locks (such as UK Community Interest Companies with statutory Asset Locks or Canadian Community Contribution Companies) or operating under binding benefit corporation charters with independent third-party social enterprise accreditation.

Ownership Archetype

Statutory CIC / C3 Asset Lock / Benefit Corporation

Executive Pay Oversight

Accredited Living Wage / Statutory CIC Director Caps

Public Disclosures

Annual CIC34 Reports / Third-Party Social Audits

Capital Leakage Risk

Very Low (Statutory Government Oversight)

TIER 3

ROBUST

85% – 89% Score

Verified Commercial Profit-Donation Covenants. Companies incorporated under standard commercial forms (Pty Ltd, LLC, Ltd) whose founders have instituted an absolute corporate covenant to donate 100% of company net profits to charitable beneficiaries. While meeting all 100% donation criteria, they operate without institutional charity ownership.

Ownership Archetype

Corporate 100% Profit-Donation / Founder Pass-Through

Executive Pay Oversight

Commercial Fiduciary Duties / Management Discretion

Public Disclosures

Corporate Accounts & Verified Charity Grant Receipts

Capital Leakage Risk

Low to Moderate (Covenant Dependent)

Addressing Executive Compensation & "Disguised Profits"

The most significant theoretical loophole in any "100% profit for good" business model is executive compensation. If a founder or CEO is free to pay themselves an inflated executive salary (e.g. paying $1M+ in a company that generates $1.2M in trading surplus), a business could claim to donate "100% of profit" while secretly extracting wealth through payroll.

Our evaluation methodology explicitly examines compensation governance:

  • Fair Market Rates Allowed: Commercial businesses need talented leaders and skilled professionals. Profit 4 Good vetting permits reasonable, competitive market-rate compensation for staff and executives.
  • Private Inurement Prohibited: Bonuses tied to profit extraction, non-market consulting fees paid to founders, or inflated salaries that reduce charitable distributions are strictly prohibited under our criteria.
  • Governance Safeguards: In Tier 1 and Tier 2 businesses, executive salaries must be determined by independent non-executive boards or published transparently in public tax disclosures (e.g. Form 990 / T3010).

Explore the directory to see verified enterprises and view each business profile's individual scoring breakdown:

Browse Verified Business Directory →